D. Adams 29oct01 1040 I just had a phone converstaion with R. D. Schaffer. He expects the Identifier class to be used for identifying all ATLAS identifiable objects. This implies that the muon identifiers will have to associated with Identifier objects. One implementations would be to for the muon identifiers to inherit from Identifier. The existing muon identifier implementation consists of helper classes to build Identifier objects. My proposal is to move this help into the specialized identifier objects (e.g. MdtChannelIdentifier). The structure of the muon (and other detectors) will be specified in XML files. It is likely these will be outside the identifier package. RD emphasized that all subdetectors should follow the same pattern for identifiers.